On December 15, 2004 - Chief Chambers and her legal team filed a 239-page “Petition for Review of Initial Decision” with the Merit Systems Protection Board.  The Petition asks the Board to reverse the Merit Systems Protection Board Administrative Judge’s conclusions that were unfavorable to the Chief and to reverse the Chief’s removal as Chief of the United States Park Police.  The petition points out 48 instances of improper action (supported with case law ) by the Administrative Judge. 

As you read the Petition, which is linked below, decide for yourself if the the Administrative Judge was biased in her approach regarding evidence that she allowed or disallowed to be admitted, her rulings on objections, and decisions she made impacting witness testimony or her prohibition of it.  As HonestChief.com promised you soon after the Merit Systems Protection Board Administrative Judge’s decision was handed down on October 6, 2004, you would soon be provided key excerpts of some remarkable moments from throughout the hearing.  Those excerpts are included word for word in various parts of the Petition.  Don’t take the HonestChief WebMaster’s  word for it – read those exchanges for yourself.